User talk:OjnoTheRed - Revision history

Debresser: Minor category fix.

2016-01-24T19:29:25Z

Minor category fix.

Zireael: /* Nice, but… */

2013-12-18T19:19:33Z

‎Nice, but…

Ahruman: Nice, but…

2007-07-11T16:32:20Z

Nice, but…

Makarius: Hi

2007-07-09T14:24:09Z

New page

== Hi ==

Hi, welcome at the wiki :) Nice work Greetings: [[User:Makarius|Makarius]] 15:24, 9 July 2007 (BST)

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 == Nice, but… ==
-Your reorganization of the OXP page is very nice, but it’s got a serious flaw: by requiring information to be updated in multiple places. This won’t work in the long run. I suggest removing all but the main list and using wiki categories for the rest (for instance, see [[:Category:Ships_OXPs]], [[:Category:Missions_OXPs]], [[:Category:Dockables_OXPs]] and [[:Category:Demo OXPs]]; you can of course add more). Making this work fully requires the fiddly job of creating pages for lots of OXPs and cross-referencing them to the relevant [[Category:Oolite Ships|ship pages]], or converting the ship pages in the case of single-ship OXPs.
+Your reorganization of the OXP page is very nice, but it’s got a serious flaw: by requiring information to be updated in multiple places. This won’t work in the long run. I suggest removing all but the main list and using wiki categories for the rest (for instance, see [[:Category:Ships_OXPs]], [[:Category:Missions_OXPs]], [[:Category:Dockables_OXPs]] and [[:Category:Demo OXPs]]; you can of course add more). Making this work fully requires the fiddly job of creating pages for lots of OXPs and cross-referencing them to the relevant [[:Category:Oolite ships|ship pages]], or converting the ship pages in the case of single-ship OXPs.
 I’m sorry I didn’t catch the issue before, but I really think redundant data on the OXP page will be a problem. That said, it’s not my wiki, so this isn’t an order. I’ll repeat this message on the forum for discussion. -[[User:Ahruman|Ahruman]] 17:32, 11 July 2007 (BST)

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 == Nice, but… ==
-Your reorganization of the OXP page is very nice, but it’s got a serious flaw: by requiring information to be updated in multiple places. This won’t work in the long run. I suggest removing all but the main list and using wiki categories for the rest (for instance, see [[:Category:Ship OXPs]], [[:Category:Mission OXPs]], [[:Category:Station OXPs]] and [[:Category:Demo OXPs]]; you can of course add more). Making this work fully requires the fiddly job of creating pages for lots of OXPs and cross-referencing them to the relevant [[:Category:Oolite Ships|ship pages]], or converting the ship pages in the case of single-ship OXPs.
+Your reorganization of the OXP page is very nice, but it’s got a serious flaw: by requiring information to be updated in multiple places. This won’t work in the long run. I suggest removing all but the main list and using wiki categories for the rest (for instance, see [[:Category:Ships_OXPs]], [[:Category:Missions_OXPs]], [[:Category:Dockables_OXPs]] and [[:Category:Demo OXPs]]; you can of course add more). Making this work fully requires the fiddly job of creating pages for lots of OXPs and cross-referencing them to the relevant [[Category:Oolite Ships|ship pages]], or converting the ship pages in the case of single-ship OXPs.
 I’m sorry I didn’t catch the issue before, but I really think redundant data on the OXP page will be a problem. That said, it’s not my wiki, so this isn’t an order. I’ll repeat this message on the forum for discussion. -[[User:Ahruman|Ahruman]] 17:32, 11 July 2007 (BST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:32, 11 July 2007
Line 2:		Line 2:

	Hi, welcome at the wiki :) Nice work Greetings: [[User:Makarius\|Makarius]] 15:24, 9 July 2007 (BST)		Hi, welcome at the wiki :) Nice work Greetings: [[User:Makarius\|Makarius]] 15:24, 9 July 2007 (BST)
		+
		+	== Nice, but… ==
		+
		+	Your reorganization of the OXP page is very nice, but it’s got a serious flaw: by requiring information to be updated in multiple places. This won’t work in the long run. I suggest removing all but the main list and using wiki categories for the rest (for instance, see [[:Category:Ship OXPs]], [[:Category:Mission OXPs]], [[:Category:Station OXPs]] and [[:Category:Demo OXPs]]; you can of course add more). Making this work fully requires the fiddly job of creating pages for lots of OXPs and cross-referencing them to the relevant [[:Category:Oolite Ships\|ship pages]], or converting the ship pages in the case of single-ship OXPs.
		+
		+	I’m sorry I didn’t catch the issue before, but I really think redundant data on the OXP page will be a problem. That said, it’s not my wiki, so this isn’t an order. I’ll repeat this message on the forum for discussion. -[[User:Ahruman\|Ahruman]] 17:32, 11 July 2007 (BST)